Detroit Sports · Tigers · Column

Eleven and a half million is fine. Chasing Skubal is not.

Lana + Tiger · As of November 13, 2026, 11:05 a.m. ET

Listen · Episode 00110:20

The companion episode: Eleven and a half million is fine. Chasing Skubal is not.

This is the first Tigers post from Points & Pennants: Detroit Sports, a companion to the show. Detroit first. The league second.

The Tigers went 76–86 this year, fourth in the American League Central. They traded Tarik Skubal midseason. They declined Kenley Jansen’s option and this week they signed Emilio Pagán, one year, $11.5 million. The labor deal expires at 11:59 p.m. ET on December 1. Eighteen days.

The signing is a yes. The price is fine. The ace stays in the past. The clock is louder than all of it.

The bullpen was a real problem. Detroit’s relief corps averaged 8.36 strikeouts per nine in 2026, third-lowest in the American League and 23rd in the majors. Scott Harris said pitching is the focus this winter, and that he wants swing-and-miss at the back of the pen. Pagán, 35, had 57 saves the last two years in Cincinnati and has averaged 10.3 strikeouts per nine for his career. He fits what Harris said out loud. One year means if he falls off, Detroit is out from under it. The closer market is thin. That’s good money: a one-year price, before the doors close, for the hole they named.

It is also fair to call the price rich. Eleven and a half million is starter-reliever money for a pitcher turning the corner on 36, on a deal Harris will not even assign a ninth-inning job to. He said fill the roster with good arms and let A.J. Hinch sort it out. Nobody should crown Pagán the closer in November. The signing is useful. Good money and a premium can both be true on a one-year deal with a date on the door.

Jacob Waguespack was re-signed November 2, one year. Will Vest threw 26 2/3 innings, then had hip and elbow surgeries in late summer; Harris expects him ready. Pagán is an add, not a new bullpen by himself.

The rotation still has Framber Valdez, three years and $115 million from February, and a young group behind him: Jackson Jobe, Troy Melton, Keider Montero, and River Ryan, who came back in the Skubal trade. Drew Anderson is expected to compete for a rotation spot, per Harris. His $10 million option is a decision we did not confirm, so it stays off this page. The club’s own outlook had Detroit opening 2026 at about $200 million in payroll, with roughly $85 million committed next season. Room is useless if you don’t use it on the right thing. Pagán is the right kind of thing. A Skubal reunion is not.

This is not a bare cupboard. Kevin McGonigle just had a Rookie of the Year-type season. Riley Greene made a third straight All-Star team. Dillon Dingler was an All-Star and a Gold Glove, with 26 home runs. Max Clark debuted on July 31. Seventy-six and eighty-six was disappointing. It is not a reason to re-enter an auction this club already left.

Jack Flaherty and Gleyber Torres are free agents. Flaherty, 31, came back in the finale after two months and threw two scoreless innings of relief, with an ERA-plus under 100 two years in a row. Torres played 96 games, a 105 OPS+ and 2.0 bWAR, called the year “awful,” and said “let’s see what’s going to happen.” Harris has been consistent: he is not building through free agency, he’s supplementing a core, and he will not block the young players. That explains a one-year reliever. It is also why a Skubal reunion would be nostalgia with a bidding-war price tag.

Skubal is a free agent who used to be theirs, a two-time Cy Young. The reporting out of the General Managers Meetings is that nearly everybody expects him to land with the Mets, with the Dodgers, Blue Jays and Padres also in the picture. A reunion, the club’s own preview said, “seems difficult.” That’s not a riddle. That’s a no. Don’t chase it. Don’t flirt with it. Leave him alone.

The neighborhood this month is the whole sport. The Associated Press, on November 1: MLB is likely to lock out the players as soon as the deal expires. The last time, in 2022, it took 99 days and opening day moved. A likely lockout is not one that’s already started. The sides have been bargaining since May, with no common ground on the main money. Owners want a cap and a floor. Players have called a cap a non-starter. On November 3 the league proposed delaying a cap-and-floor system until 2028, at a projected $258.2 million cap and $180.2 million floor. That’s their offer. It’s not a deal. If you’re waiting on a second arm, the calendar is eighteen days, not “sometime this winter.” A one-year reliever before that date is not a small nothing. Call it rich. It got done.

The test: if Detroit adds another arm that fits Harris’s own description before December 1, then “pitching is the focus” showed up again. If they get to the deadline with Pagán and Waguespack as the winter, that’s the winter we will say they had. If they start a public tour of a Skubal reunion, the grade stands. We will not change the standard in January.

Sources

Independent fan commentary. No team or league affiliation. No guaranteed result or betting recommendation.

Independent fan commentary. No team or league affiliation. Not a betting show.